David Divine’s 20-Year Journey on the Sale of 650 Acres in Clayton

Congratulations to David Divine, SIOR, Director of Commercial Investment Sales, for representing the seller in the sale of 173 acres in Clayton. This is the first of two closings planned for a combined 350-acre tract situated north of downtown Clayton, off of No. O’Neil Street. The buyer is Pulte Homes, which is developing the 750-home ‘Carolina Overlook,’ a 55+ Del Webb community.

The 173 acres sold on October 31st for $20 million, or roughly $115,600 per acre. The second closing on the remaining 177 acres is scheduled for October 2025.

The Carolina Overlook community was recently featured in the Triangle Business Journal.  You can learn about the history and hurdles of gaining rezoning approval for the project here. The crux of the debate centered on the impact on traffic the project would have on the small town of just over 30,000.

David Divine has managed the sales process for this land, originally 650 acres, starting in 2005. That’s not a typo – David’s representation of the seller began almost 20 years ago. We asked him to share the story of this timeline – through the real estate market crash of ‘08, and the changing lending environments and interest rates since.

From David Divine –

“The Earp family hired me to sell their 650 acres of family land back in 2005. We went under contract for the entire acreage fairly quickly with a developer out of New Jersey. They were not able to close because the lending environment quickly changed due to the housing market crash in 2007. The buyer walked away from a significant amount of earnest money. They were under contract in 2005 for $17 million or $26,000 per acre for the entire 650 acres.

We took the property off the market during the “great recession ” through 2011 and went back to market in 2012. We went under contract with another developer for the entirety of the 650 acres. They proceeded to site plan approve the entire property but did not close in the end. We had another developer do the same thing, and they walked away from a large earnest money deposit as well in 2019-2020.

The owners decided to take the northern acreage of 350 acres off the market, and only offer the southern acreage of 300 acres for sale.  Pulte Homes ultimately purchased the southern 300 acres for, at that time in 2021, a market value of $35,000 per acre. Pulte is developing the southern acreage into their signature Del Webb community, and it still being built out.

In 2022, we decided to market the northern 350 acres for sale.  I contacted the top 10 national and regional builders in the Triangle area, and we initially went under contract with MI Homes. MI Homes decided to walk away after interest rates began to spike in June 2022. After interest rates went from 3% to 6.5%, they felt they could no longer pay the price they agreed to. Pulte returned to the table and agreed to purchase the northern 350 acres for $40 million or roughly $115,000 per acre. They just closed on Oct 31, 2024, on 173 of the 300 acres for $20 million and will be closing on the other half of the property for $20 million in October 2025. As you can see above, residential land prices went from $26,000 per acre in 2005 for 650 acres to $35,000 per acre in 2020 to $115,000 per acre in 2024. The appreciation of residential land in the Triangle over the past 4 years is historic and unprecedented.

I have had the pleasure of working with the property owners for 20 years, from 2005 to 2025. There have been some great things that have occurred and some sad things as well. Sadly, Ray Earp, who inherited the land along with his sister Mary “Winkie” Worley from their father, had an accident on his tractor and passed away back in 2013. This was devastating to the entire family. Ray’s wonderful wife Nancy had to step up and help run the family business with their son, Raymond “Chip” Earp. Winkie and Nancy have been great stewards of their family land. It has been an absolute pleasure working with them over the years.”

Recent Posts

APG Advisors Announces Key Promotions
APG Advisors is thrilled to announce the promotion of both David Batten and David Stroud, to Senior Vice President. David Batten serves the greater Triangle region, specializing in Land Services and I...

November 19, 2024

David Divine’s 20-Year Journey on the Sale of 650 Acres in Clayton
Congratulations to David Divine, SIOR, Director of Commercial Investment Sales, for representing the seller in the sale of 173 acres in Clayton. This is the first of two closings planned for a combine...

November 7, 2024

Congratulations to Sherry Wilborn, Newly Elected to the Person County Board of Commissioners
We’re thrilled to announce that APG’s Commercial Real Estate Advisor, Sherry Wilborn, serving Person County and surrounding areas, won her race last night for the Person County Board of Commissioners!...

November 6, 2024

APG Capital Completes Successful Sale of Ace Plaza in Cary, NC
APG Capital is pleased to announce the successful sale of Ace Plaza, a 54,800-square-foot multi-tenant retail property anchored by Ace Hardware, along Kildaire Farm Rd in Cary, NC. Originally built in...

October 31, 2024

APG’s Commitment to Tackling Both Economic and Social Issues
Jim Anthony of APG has long been at the forefront of addressing critical societal issues. In last year’s short-form documentary, produced by the ViewPoint Project with Dennis Quaid, Jim highlighted th...

September 13, 2024

SOLD! All 3 Outparcels at Broadstone Station
We are excited to announce the successful sale of all three outparcels at Broadstone Station, a prominent residential mixed-use development located at the busy intersection of US 1 and NC 55 in Apex, ...

September 12, 2024

The Power of Broker Connections
We’d like to give a shout out to APG’s own Colby Mitchell and Greyson Tavolacci on their tenant representation in the leasing of 8820 Westgate Park Drive in Northwest Raleigh, a 7,500+ square foot fle...

August 28, 2024

APG Congratulates Our Q2 2024 CoStar Power Broker Award Winners
Congratulations to APG’s David Divine, Director of Investments Sales, and Daniel Walser, Vice President, Acquisitions for being named CoStar Power Brokers for Q2 2024. David and Daniel received this a...

August 9, 2024

Sold! Northeast Raleigh Office Property
Congratulations to David Divine, SIOR and Director of Investment Sales with APG Advisors, and Daniel Walser, Vice President at APG Capital and manager of the syndication division, for their seller rep...

August 2, 2024

Catching up with one of APG’s Veteran Land Brokers
Philip Matthews, Vice President of Land & Investment Sales Any new projects you’d like to share news and updates about? It was recently made public that Storyliving by Disney is partnering with DM...

July 9, 2024

Sold! Northwest Raleigh Retail Property
Congratulations to Lee Holder, Senior Vice President and David Divine, SIOR, Director of Investment Sales for their Seller Representation in the successful sale of 3501 W. Millbrook Road – a 6,448 squ...

June 13, 2024

Key Takeaway from 2024 I-85 Industrial Conference
Jim Anthony joined the Five Markets panel at last week’s conference. “The I-85 Industrial Conference held in Charlotte last week was a great success, as expected. Kudos to the France Media team for a ...

May 31, 2024

APG Companies Launches Our Promise Care Homes
Brian Quenneville, John Zemet and Jim Anthony are pleased to announce a new portfolio venture business within APG Companies: “Our Promise Care Homes”. OPCH was founded to provide personalized individu...

May 31, 2024

APG Capital Celebrates Sale of Fully Leased Industrial Property in Wilmington
APG Capital has closed on the sale of a 93,508 square foot industrial building at 3881 US Hwy 421 North in Wilmington. The single-tenant building has been home to Ferguson Enterprises since 2009, who ...

April 22, 2024

Triangle Business Journal Highlights APG Capital’s Latest Venture in Selma, NC
APG Capital has acquired four parcels totaling 70 acres along I-95 in fast growing Johnston County, North Carolina. The property, which is situated at 190 Campground Road in Selma, was purchased last ...

April 16, 2024

David Stroud Receives TCAR Elite Broker Award for Industrial Leasing
Congratulations to APG’s David Stroud, Vice President of Industrial Leasing for being one of the winners of TCAR’s Elite Broker Award for 2023. Among the list of key deals for the year, David provided...

April 10, 2024

APG Celebrates Broker Awards for 2023
Congratulations to APG’s top three brokers for 2023: David Stroud, Vice President – Industrial; David Batten, Vice President and Broker in Charge; and David Divine, Director of Commercial Investment S...

March 29, 2024

APG Advisors Celebrates Successful Sale of GSA Leased Building in Raleigh
Congratulations to David Divine and Rick Polley, who provided seller representation in the successful sale of a 28,321 square foot office building at 2625 Appliance Court in Raleigh, located just off ...

February 28, 2024

APG Capital Acquires Overlook Office Building in Durham
APG Capital is pleased to announce its latest venture: the acquisition of “Overlook”, a 97,074 square-foot, four-story office building, situated in Creekstone Park in Durham. Primary tenant Duke Unive...

February 22, 2024

APG Supported Metropolitan Village Welcomes First Tenants
We gratefully celebrate APG Capital’s Jim Anthony and John Zemet, the development partners to Charlotte based Liberty Atlantic, on the inspirational story of Metropolitan Village, a signature workforc...

December 14, 2023

APG Capital Celebrates the Successful Disposition of South Carolina Industrial Site
APG Capital is pleased to announce the successful sale of 100 Schmid Plaza; a 110,000 square-foot, Class B industrial facility situated along the I-85 corridor in Anderson, South Carolina. Deal Return...

October 31, 2023

Jim Anthony Discusses the Housing Affordability Crisis
APG’s CEO and Founder Jim Anthony discusses the escalating housing affordability crisis in a segment of the Viewpoint Project with Dennis Quaid – short-form documentaries produced for Public Televisio...

October 12, 2023

APG Advisors Celebrates Success in Landlord Representation and Leasing
APG Advisors is pleased to share news of several office lease deals executed in recent weeks. Congratulations to Martie Serianni who provided landlord representation in three lease deals signed at One...

August 9, 2023

Takeaways from the I-85 Industrial Conference
The 2023 conference was a success – and very well attended. APG’s Jim Anthony participated on the Market Insight Panel and here are some of the key takeaways: Industrial remains a leading asset class...

May 24, 2023

APG Capital Completes Sale of Property for Affordable Housing Development
APG Capital recently completed the sale of 16 acres on Carr Road in Durham to the Taft-Mills Group. Geoff Loftin and the late Jim Flink brokered the deal for APG. The property sold for $2.7 million, $...

April 25, 2023

APG Capital Takes Quantum Stride with Triangle Land Acquisition
APG Capital led an investor group to acquire 307 acres in East Raleigh along Buffaloe Road and Robertson Grove Road known as River Towne. The partially developed tract is zoned and planned for a devel...

March 16, 2023

Dealmakers of the Month
APG is pleased to announce Philip Matthews and David Batten as our Dealmakers of the Month. Continue reading for a recap of a job well done. 1164 North Main Street, Wake Forest NC Sale of 18 Acres of ...

February 9, 2023

Where Thoughtful Commercial Real Estate Experts Transform Communities...
“Commercial real estate has the power to transform communities. We love to solve problems, create value, and drive success for our community and clients,” says Jim Anthony, founder and CEO of Raleigh-...

January 23, 2023

APG Advisors Announces Key Promotions
APG Advisors is thrilled to announce the promotion of both David Batten and David Stroud, to Senior Vice President. David Batten serves the great...
David Divine’s 20-Year Journey on the Sale of 650 ...
Congratulations to David Divine, SIOR, Director of Commercial Investment Sales, for representing the seller in the sale of 173 acres in Clayton. ...
Congratulations to Sherry Wilborn, Newly Elected t...
We’re thrilled to announce that APG’s Commercial Real Estate Advisor, Sherry Wilborn, serving Person County and surrounding areas, won her race l...
APG Capital Completes Successful Sale of Ace Plaza...
APG Capital is pleased to announce the successful sale of Ace Plaza, a 54,800-square-foot multi-tenant retail property anchored by Ace Hardware, ...
APG’s Commitment to Tackling Both Economic and Soc...
Jim Anthony of APG has long been at the forefront of addressing critical societal issues. In last year’s short-form documentary, produced by the ...
SOLD! All 3 Outparcels at Broadstone Station
We are excited to announce the successful sale of all three outparcels at Broadstone Station, a prominent residential mixed-use development locat...
Scroll to Top